Really interesting. But as I read in your quote, RedHat says "all the code in
Red Hat products is [...] licensed under the GPL [...]. So you always have free
access to the source code.
For me, the GPL does not only give the free access to the code, but also the
freedom to execute and redistribute the software.
Extract from the fsf web site: (
http://www.fsf.org/philosophy/free-sw.html)
Free software [...] refers to four kinds of freedom, for the users of the
software:
* The freedom to run the program [...] (freedom 0).
[...]
* The freedom to redistribute copies [...] (freedom 2).
[...]
My problem is that the terms of the "Software and service terms and conditions"
under which RedHat distributes Linux in EMEA deny the right to the customer to
copy freely the GPL'ed software, and explicitely deny the right to freely run
the software on as many computers as the user wants, which is exactly opposed
the the very GPL terms:
(
http://www.fsf.org/copyleft/gpl.html, point 6)
6. Each time you redistribute the Program [...], the recipient automatically
receives a license from the original licensor to copy, distribute or modify the
Program [...]. You may NOT IMPOSE ANY FURTHER RESTRICTIONS on the recipients'
exercise of the rights granted herein.
For me, RedHat redistributes GPL'ed software, but impose restrictions on the
user's right on the software, by imposing a subscription to RedHet Network for
any supplementary host running the software, physical control of the amount of
hosts running the software, and prohibition to run the software after the
subsciption to RedHat Network ended.
I'm still waiting for FSF conclusion on this.
Patrick Kaell <sparc(a)kayoon.net> wrote:
Brent Frère wrote:
Redhat is
fully GPL'ed (inclusive the installer).
This is a valuable information to me.
I have now found the place where it is written:
http://www.redhat.com/software/rhel/faq/#4
<quote>
Except for a few components provided by third parties (for example,
Java) all the code in Red Hat products is open source and licensed under
the GPL (or a similar license, such as the LGPL). So you always have
free access to the source code.
</quote>
So, if you do not look at Java and some other few components, which you
do not have to install (and which are missing in Fedora anyway) for a
working copy, Redhat is fully GPL'ed (inclusive the installer). It may
even not be too hard to remove these few packages (RPMs) from the ISOs
yourself.
Greetings, Patrick Kaell
--
--
Brent Frère
Private e-mail: Brent(a)BFrere.net
Postal address: 5, rue de Mamer
L-8280 Kehlen
Grand-Duchy of Luxembourg
European Union
Mobile: +352-021/29.05.98
Fax: +352-26.30.05.96
Home: +352-307.341
URL:
http://BFrere.net